Sermon text: Matthew 21:33–44

The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, the love of God, and the fellowship of the Holy Spirit be with you all. Amen.

Some have claimed that the definition of insanity is to repeat the same action and expect different results. In our parable, we see a master who seems insane. Imagine sending a second messenger when the recipients of the first messenger hurt him badly, killed another, stoned a third. Would you have sent the second and the third, let alone the fourth and fifth, sixth and seventh? The master keeps sending messengers. Fool the master once, shame on the tenants. Fool the master seven times, shame on the master. Would you keep sending messengers and pursuing a relationship with an enemy that showed you such hatred? This seems to be foolish or insane, but it's really neither. It's in fact love. It's God's love that He sends prophets and apostles, evangelists and teachers, and others to hostile people to share the good news. The love of God is so great, He even sent His only-begotten Son, already knowing what the people of the earth would do to Him. He sent His Son that sinners might be forgiven. God's not crazy. He's not foolish. He simply loves. And we hear it in the voice of Jesus as He enters Jerusalem on that last visit: "O Jerusalem, Jerusalem." Likewise, the prophets and the apostles go forth in love, preaching to people they know will persecute them. We love because He first loved us. So we too keep speaking the Gospel even in the face of open hostility. This is not foolish. This is love.

This morning's parable is not a subtle parable. Its meaning is not hard to divine. Jesus uses the image of Isaiah 5:1–7 and the image of Psalm 80:8–16. These two passages serve as the foundation for Jesus' own parable this morning in the Gospel. These two texts were well known to the priests and elders, and just about any mildly educated Jew. Most of the players in the parable are pretty easy to identify. The landowner is God the Father. The vineyard is the church, the Hebrew people, Old Testament Israel. The tenants are the Jews, specifically the religious leaders of the Jews. The wall, winepress, and tower represent aspects of the temple, the worship of God, the Word of God, the sacrificial system, and the offices required to carry out the ministry of God's Word. The owner of the vineyard sends two waves of servants to collect what he's owed. The two groups are represented by Old Testament prophets. One group is the greater prophets, whose names we know because their names are on the books, the scrolls of the Old Testament. The other are the lesser prophets, who served as rabbis and priests, whose names are unknown, who did their jobs in and out of season, faithfully, frequently in the face of persecution. The new tenants that will take over the vineyard are the Gentiles, who will come into the church in the wake of the Jews' rejection of the Gospel. The son of the landowner is, of course, Jesus Christ, the Savior. Seven hundred years before Jesus, God sent Isaiah, one of the greater prophets, to sing a song and tell a parable about God and His relationship to the people of Israel. We heard that read: "Let me sing now for my well-beloved, a song of my beloved concerning his vineyard."

In this morning's parable, Jesus retold Isaiah's parable and applied it to the religious leaders of His day. He said to them, "Listen to another parable. There was a landowner who planted a vineyard and put a wall around it and dug a winepress in it and built a tower." In telling the parable, Jesus was bringing to mind the picture painted by Isaiah chapter 5 — the picture of the Lord God who loves His children, Israel, and who took great care in building and planting a vineyard. Isaiah took great care in describing just how the Lord God went about building the vineyard. The vineyard was the owner's first love, for He dug all around it, removed its stones, planted it with the choicest of vines. He built a tower in it and hewed out a wine vat in it. He also put a wall and a fence around it. The Lord God prepared the ground, gave the vineyard protection, built a tower for a watchman to watch over the people for approaching danger. He planted the best vines to grow the best grapes, and put the best winepress in so that He could make the best wine. In both Isaiah and Jesus' parable, the Lord God did everything to make His vineyard, so that it would be fruitful and pleasing both to Him and to His people.

When all was ready, the master leased his vineyard to tenants. All the tenants had to do was their job: share the firstfruits with the vine owner. It was a partnership, after all, and the landowner rightfully was owed his share of the profits. But when the harvest came, the owner sent the servants to collect what was owed him. But the tenants had forgotten that they were in the vineyard only because the owner had prepared it for them and placed them in it. The landowner sent his servants to the vine growers to receive his produce. And the vine growers took his servants and beat one, killed another, stoned a third. And again he sent another group of servants, larger than the first, and they did the same thing to them. Bible scholars divide these prophets into former prophets and latter prophets. One of the latter prophets was Jeremiah, and he was beaten and imprisoned. Oral tradition says that even the great Isaiah was martyred — he was sawn in two under the orders of King Manasseh. Zechariah was stoned to death in the temple. John the Baptizer was beheaded. The tenants in the parable schemed to take something and make it their own, but they had no right to. They conspired to make themselves masters of their own vineyard. And remember, the vineyard is the church — the people of God who exist around His Word and Sacrament ministry. They plan to take control of the church in an effort to self-deify.

Until recently, some of Jesus' parables seemed a bit far-fetched. Some of the characters in His parables just act in the most outrageous ways. Common-sense people, and people of faith, often found it hard to understand why Jesus would put such stupid characters in His parables. The action that some of them undertook was simply contrary to their own self-interest. For example, a wedding guest who rejects the required and provided wedding gown is thrown out of the banquet. An unforgiving servant who is forgiven a fortune is freed, only to turn around and jail his fellow servant who owes him a little. The people were invited to a wedding feast for free food and joyful celebration, but they didn't come, so the homeless and downtrodden were invited to take their place. In today's parable, a father sends his son to a murderous clan that is trying to steal something they can't have, and who will most certainly face justice in the end. Given what we're seeing in our own time — in our own schools and our own streets and our own halls of government, where people are doing the most destructive things to the established institutions, traditions, and laws — it has now become easy to believe how stupid these people can act, or how our people can act just as stupidly. Such people destroy and kill, and that gets them the power they seek. We would all do well to listen to 1 Corinthians 4:7: "What do you have that you did not receive?" Or James 1:17: "Every good thing given and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights, with whom there is no variation or shifting shadow."

Two groups of servants were sent to collect what was owed, and all were rejected, and some murdered. And what was owed? The harvest the owner was looking for was faith: fidelity to the Word of God, the right doctrine, true worship services, and the receiving of His promised Messiah, His very own Son. These are the things that the owner sought from the people of his land. The tenants weren't the only ones acting in a contrary way to their own self-interest. The owner himself appears to be doing the same thing. After the first group of messengers were rejected and killed, the master reasoned to himself, "They will respect my son." Seriously? They'll respect his son after killing seven of his servants? Is the owner among the group of stupid people, acting unwisely? "They will respect my son." No, they didn't. But when the tenants saw the son, they said to themselves, "This is the heir. Come, let us kill him and have his inheritance." And they took him and threw him out of the vineyard and killed him. So Jesus says to His audience, "Did you never read in the Scriptures: 'The stone which the builders rejected has become the chief cornerstone'? This came about from the Lord, and is marvelous in our eyes."

Jesus, the teller of the parable, was not naive about the motives and the ending of the parable, which by the end was looking more like a metaphor for the history of Israel and a prophecy of what was about to happen to God's very own Son. They were in the process of rejecting the stone, the church's one foundation. The father and the son in the parable knew what would happen, just as God the Father and God the Son, Jesus, knew what was going to happen. God the Father not only knew His Son would die — He purposed His Son's death. It's a picture of God's love for us, His patience with us, His grace with us, the lengths to which the two of them would go to save us from our sins. That's why He concluded the parable with Psalm 118:22: "It is marvelous in our eyes." What took place on Good Friday did not appear to be marvelous, but it was, just the same. That's the idea here.

Jesus asked the religious leaders, "When therefore the owner of the vineyard comes, what will he do to those tenants?" And everybody knew the right answer: the owner will put those wretches to a miserable death and let out the vineyard to other tenants who will give him the fruits in their seasons. They have the right answer. The problem is they don't see themselves as the villains in the parable. They don't see themselves as the ones rejecting the prophets, though they refused to answer the question last week about John's baptism: "Is it from men, or is it from God?" Even though they're planning on putting to death Jesus — theirs is a justified killing in their mind, for Jesus is committing blasphemy — they just don't see themselves as miserable sinners. They see themselves as righteous executioners. And we, all sinners, ought to see ourselves in every parable that we read as the stupid one, the sinful one, the ones who do dumb things and terrible things. We are the sinners in Jesus' parables. And Jesus is always the hero in the parables. He's the one who does rightly: the one who forgives, the one who loves, the one who cares, the one who heals, the one who feeds, the one who opens up blind eyes, the one who sacrifices even Himself for the ones who do wrong.

"I say to you, the kingdom of God will be taken away from you and be given to a nation producing fruit." In the immediate context, Jesus was telling the religious leaders of His day that their rejection of Him, of His Father, of the Holy Spirit, and of His words and teachings would result in the kingdom of God being given to another nation that would produce fruit. In Jesus' day, that was the Gentiles. He is saying here what He said to some Pharisees on Palm Sunday. Some of the Pharisees in the crowd said to Jesus, "Teacher, rebuke your disciples." And Jesus said, "I tell you, if these become silent, the stones will cry out." Yet Jesus warns that the kingdom will be taken from them, the faithless, and given to another. "The one who falls on this stone," He says, "will be broken into pieces. And when it falls on anyone, it will crush him." God kills in order to make alive, for it is God who creates life and faith out of death and disbelief.

By God's grace, little Immanuel has had the kingdom of heaven with her from her beginning. Not many so-called Christian congregations can say that these days. A great many have rejected the Christ of God, the Christ of Scripture. They've rejected His words and His teachings. They've rejected even His name as Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. But He has chosen us, His new Israel, to be a blessing to all people. Today is our day to produce the fruits of God's vineyard, namely faith, repentance, hope, and love. The God who is Father, the God who is Son, seemingly act against their own self-interest when the Son of God took on flesh and sacrificed Himself on a cross to save us from our sins and bring us into the heavenly vineyard. He has given everything we need: His Son, His Word, the gift of faith, all good works that faith produces. He has given Himself — His own person, His shed blood, His glorious resurrection. All of it He has given to us in the waters of Holy Baptism, and sustains us in the Sacrament of His very body and blood. So, welcome to the vineyard. You're in the kingdom. Your sins are forgiven. Amen.

Nineteenth Sunday after Pentecost, 2026 – The Love That Keeps Sending

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *